Comparison
Four ways to run a 10–500 truck back office
We are obviously not neutral. So rather than a feature table where every row happens to favour us, here is what each option is genuinely good at, who it fits, and where it stops working — including where DispatchTrace stops working.
| Capability | Spreadsheets + QuickBooks | Dispatch-only tools | Enterprise TMS | DispatchTrace |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Built for | Under ~10 trucks | Any size, dispatch focus | 500+ trucks | 10–500 trucks |
| Dispatch board | Manual, single editor | Strong | Strong, highly configurable | Real-time, multi-user |
| Driver settlements | By hand | Basic or none | Comprehensive | Six pay types, automated |
| Recurring deductions | Manual each week | Rare | Usually yes | Scheduled engine, runs daily |
| Compliance tracking | A binder or a folder | Usually a separate product | Included | Built in, two-phase alerts |
| Roadside document access | Paper in the cab | Rare | Varies | QR + PIN digital permit book |
| Document data entry | Typed by a person | Typed by a person | Varies, often EDI-based | AI extraction, six document types |
| Factoring workflow | Manual | Rare | Usually yes | Batch + export, AI reconciliation |
| Accounting | QuickBooks, re-keyed | Export to accounting | Full ledger | Trucking finance only, no GL |
| Load board connection | Copy and paste | Often integrated | Often integrated | Not integrated |
| ELD coverage | Separate portal | Broad | Broad | EVA and Hive only |
| Driver mobile app | No | Common | Common | No |
| Time to first load | Immediate | Days to weeks | Months | Same day |
| Pricing model | Near zero, plus your time | Typically per seat | Licence + implementation | $100/mo + $1 per load |
| Cost of adding office staff | None | Another seat | Another seat | None |
Categories, not named products. Where a competitor’s pricing or implementation time is quoted anywhere on this site, it should link to that vendor’s own published material — so this page does not quote any.
Option one
Spreadsheets and QuickBooks
The most common setup in the industry, and genuinely the right answer for a while.
What it is good at
Free, instant, and infinitely flexible. Nobody needs training. You can restructure the whole thing on a Tuesday because a customer changed how they want reference numbers. For an owner-operator or a five-truck carrier, software would be overhead.
Where it stops
Not at the dispatch sheet — at the second and third one. Driver pay grows its own workbook, deductions grow another, and none of them agree. Two dispatchers cannot safely edit at once. A settlement dispute becomes an afternoon of reconstruction, and compliance lives in a folder nobody opens until something expires.
Move when
Around ten to twenty drivers, or the first time a driver is underpaid and you cannot prove why within five minutes.
Option two
Dispatch-only software
Tools built around the board, sold per seat, often with a driver app.
What it is good at
The board itself is usually excellent, and better than ours in places — many have mature load board and ELD integrations and a real driver app. If your problem is purely visibility of who is on what load, this category solves it well.
Where it stops
After delivery. Settlements are basic or absent, deduction schedules usually are not there at all, and compliance is a separate purchase. You end up with a good board and the same three spreadsheets behind it — plus a per-seat bill that grows every time you hire in the office.
Move when
The work that hurts has moved from dispatching the load to paying for it.
Option three
Enterprise TMS
The established platforms built for large asset-based carriers.
What it is good at
Depth and configurability that nothing in this comparison matches. Full general ledger, EDI, mature integrations, and decades of edge cases already handled. If you are running 800 trucks with an operations department, this is the correct category and we are not a substitute.
Where it stops
At the size below it. The licence and the implementation both assume a dedicated project team, and the configurability that makes it powerful at 800 trucks makes it slow to stand up at 50. Carriers this size routinely buy it and use a fraction of it.
Choose it when
You are above roughly 500 trucks, need EDI with large shippers, or want your ledger and your TMS to be one system.
Option four
DispatchTrace
Built for the gap: too big for spreadsheets, too small for an implementation project.
What it is good at
Dispatch, driver settlement and compliance being one system rather than three, so a delivered load turns into an invoice, a driver payment and a compliance record without anyone re-keying it. AI extraction removes most of the typing. Pricing does not punish you for adding office staff. It runs the same day you sign up.
Where it stops
No driver app. No load board or QuickBooks connector. ELD support covers EVA and Hive only. No IFTA calculation or FMCSA filing, no card payments, US operations only. If two or three of those are dealbreakers, one of the categories above fits you better and it is cheaper to find out now.
Choose it when
You run 10 to 500 trucks, the pain is in settlements and compliance as much as dispatch, and you want to be live this week.
Questions
Choosing between them
When do spreadsheets stop working for a trucking company?
Usually somewhere around ten to twenty drivers. The breaking point is rarely the dispatch sheet itself — it is the second and third spreadsheet that grow beside it for driver pay and deductions, and the fact that no two of them agree. Once a settlement dispute takes an afternoon to resolve, the spreadsheet is costing more than software would.
What is the difference between a TMS and dispatch software?
Dispatch software covers the board: who is on what load, and where it is. A transportation management system also covers what happens after delivery — invoicing the customer, paying the driver, applying deductions, submitting to a factor, and tracking the compliance documents that keep the truck legal. Most tools sold as dispatch software have basic or no settlement and compliance functionality.
Is an enterprise TMS worth it for a 50-truck fleet?
Rarely. Enterprise platforms are built for carriers above roughly 500 trucks, and their cost and multi-month implementation assume a dedicated project team and an operations department to configure them. A 50-truck carrier usually cannot absorb either, and ends up using a fraction of what it bought.
What should a mid-size carrier look for in a TMS?
That dispatch, driver settlement and compliance are one system rather than three that need reconciling; that adding office staff does not increase the bill; that it can be running the same week rather than the next quarter; and that the vendor is specific about what it does not do, particularly around ELD, accounting and load board connections.
Still not sure it fits?
Book a 30-minute call and tell us your fleet size. If the answer is that you should stay on spreadsheets for another year, we will say so.